Adding a new product to your range can be exciting. It might be a new wine style, a seasonal beer, a different spirit or a limited release designed to attract a new group of customers.
But while producers often spend time thinking about what to add, they don’t always give the same attention to what should be removed.
Over time, product ranges can grow without much being taken out. Older products remain available because they have always been there, a small group of customers still buys them, or nobody has stopped to question whether they are worth continuing.
The result can be a range that looks impressive but is increasingly difficult to manage.
Every product requires ingredients, packaging, production time, inventory management and attention. Some products justify those resources. Others may be quietly creating more work than the value they bring back.
The question isn’t simply how many products a business should offer. It’s whether each one still has a good reason to be there.
The Hidden Cost of a Large Product Range
The cost of making a product goes beyond its ingredients and direct production expenses.
Every additional product can introduce another layer of operational complexity.
Consider a brewery with several seasonal and core beer lines. Each might require a different recipe, ingredients, design, label or packaging format. Even if some products sell in relatively small quantities, the brewery still needs to manage the materials and production requirements associated with them.
The same applies to wineries and distilleries. Different bottle formats, closures, labels, recipes and packaging specifications all create additional stock items to purchase, store and monitor.
There are also production implications. Switching between products can require cleaning, equipment adjustments, recipe changes and preparation. Smaller production runs may mean more frequent changeovers and less time spent producing.
Inventory becomes more complicated too. Producers need to forecast demand for each product, maintain appropriate stock levels and avoid purchasing materials that may not be used for months.
Individually, these requirements might seem manageable. Across a large range, however, they can add up.
When Good Sales Figures Hide a Poor Product
A product can sell consistently and still be a poor use of business resources. Sales figures tell producers how much revenue a product generates, but they don’t necessarily show the full cost of keeping it in the range.
For example, imagine a distillery producing two spirits. One sells in larger quantities and uses standard ingredients and packaging. The other sells less frequently but requires specialist ingredients, a separate production process and packaging that is more expensive to source.
The second product might have a higher selling price, but that doesn’t automatically make it more commercially attractive.
Producers need to consider the costs associated with the entire process, including labour, production time, packaging, storage and any additional handling required.
There is also the question of opportunity cost. If a product takes up tank space, production time or storage capacity, what else could the business be doing with those resources?
Warning Signs That a Product Needs Reviewing
There isn’t one figure that tells a producer when a product should be discontinued. However, there are several signs that it may be time to take a closer look.
Sales are declining over time. A product that has gradually lost demand over several seasons may no longer be relevant to customers. One quiet month isn’t necessarily a reason to act, but a consistent decline deserves attention.
Stock is taking longer to sell. If finished goods are sitting in storage for extended periods, the business may be tying up cash and storage space in products that aren’t moving quickly enough.
Production runs are becoming inefficient. Small batches can be worthwhile, particularly for premium or limited-release products. But if the setup and changeover requirements are significant compared with the quantity produced, the economics may no longer make sense.
Ingredients or packaging are difficult to manage. A product that relies on specialist materials, high minimum order quantities or suppliers with long lead times can create additional purchasing and inventory challenges.
Margins are consistently weak. Rising costs, outdated pricing or inefficient production methods can gradually reduce the value a product contributes to the business.
It competes with another product in the range. Sometimes two products appeal to much the same customers without generating enough additional sales to justify keeping both.
These signs don’t automatically mean a product should disappear. They indicate that it deserves a proper review rather than being left in the range by default.
Not Every Underperforming Product Needs to Go
Before discontinuing a product, producers should consider whether there is a way to improve its performance or reduce the resources it requires.
Sometimes the issue is pricing. A product may still have strong demand, but its selling price hasn’t kept pace with rising production or packaging costs.
In other cases, the product itself isn’t the problem. The production schedule might be. Making it less frequently or increasing batch sizes could reduce the time and effort involved.
Packaging may also be worth reviewing. A product that uses a separate bottle or can format could potentially be moved into a more standard format, provided this doesn’t compromise its positioning or customer appeal.
There are also products that serve a purpose beyond their immediate sales figures.
A limited-release whisky, unusual wine variety or seasonal beer might sell in relatively small quantities but attract new customers, strengthen the producer’s reputation or encourage buyers to explore other products in the range.
A product like this shouldn’t be judged on volume alone. Its wider contribution to the business needs to be considered.
The important distinction is between a product that sells slowly but serves a valuable purpose and one that continues to consume resources without providing a meaningful return.
Making the Decision With Better Business Information
Reviewing a product range requires more than looking at a sales report.
Producers need to understand how products perform across sales, production, inventory and costs. Looking at these areas separately can make it difficult to see the full picture.
For each product, it is worth reviewing:
Sales history: Is demand growing, stable or declining?
Product costs: What does it actually cost to produce and package?
Inventory: How much finished stock and raw material is being held?
Stock movement: How quickly does the product sell once it is made?
Production requirements: How much time, capacity and preparation does it require?
Purchasing commitments: Are there minimum order quantities or materials that are difficult to use elsewhere?
Having this information available makes it easier to identify products that are performing well, products that need attention and products that may no longer justify their place.
It also helps producers avoid making decisions based on assumptions. A product that appears successful from its sales figures may look quite different once its production and inventory requirements are taken into account.
Connected sales, inventory, costing and manufacturing information can help bring these different parts of the business together. This is particularly useful when a producer has a growing range and needs a clearer understanding of what each product requires.
Making Room for Better Opportunities
Removing a product can feel like a step backwards, particularly if it has been part of the business for years. But maintaining a large range isn’t automatically a sign of growth or success.
A more focused range can make purchasing, production planning and inventory management easier. It can reduce the number of materials that need to be held, simplify production schedules and free up capacity for products with stronger demand or better commercial potential.
That doesn’t mean producers should stop experimenting or introducing new products. Innovation and variety remain important, particularly in industries where customer preferences and market conditions continue to change.
The challenge is making sure that new products have a clear purpose and that existing ones are reviewed regularly.
A product shouldn’t keep its place simply because it has always been there. It should earn that place through the value it brings to the business, whether that is through sales, margin, customer loyalty, reputation or a wider strategic role.
Sometimes the best decision for a product range isn’t adding something new. It’s recognising when something no longer belongs.
Vinsight is the producer of Sales, Inventory and Manufacturing software for the wine, beer and spirits industry.






